Frozen Frozen Embryo Ownership - 1012 Words

Emely Santana Mr. Pumphrey Period 7 1/9/17 Frozen Embryo Ownership With the touchy topic of frozen embryos, many controversial questions come to mind. Perhaps the most controversial of all is in the case of divorce, who has the rights to the frozen embryos? The true questions is, should a frozen embryo be regarded as a person, property, or something else entirely? Many see freezing an embryo as freezing a baby, and others see it as property as it is not implanted in the mother and doesn t have the capability of deciding on its own or feeling pain. An embryo is a fertilized egg in its earliest stages of development. An embryo is formed when sperm fertilizes an egg. Cryoprotectants are to eliminate the formation of ice during†¦show more content†¦For people who feel like embryos are like fetuses this option does not sit well with them. In the case of a divorce the two parents can also destroy them, donate them to an infertile couple, donate them to science or go through a custody battle. Disputes over the ownership of the frozen embryos depend on how courts legally classify the embryos. Donna M. Sheinbach states, â€Å"If the courts consider the embryos to be unborn children they will use a â€Å" best interest of the child † analysis based on family law principles to decide which parent prevails in the custody battle. If the courts classify the embryos as personal property they will apply it to property law as if the embryos were automobiles or jewelry. If the embryos are determined to be neither persons or pro perty but something in between, the applicable regime is constitutional law.† Although many couples partake in freezing their embryos, others find it inhumane and unnatural. Many see it as freezing a baby and correlate it to the subject of abortion. Some couples see the act of freezing embryos to later have them transferred into the mother’s uterus as unnatural, for intercourse did not take place in the creation of the fetus. Another issue couples have is that freezing embryos and transferring them is a costly deed. Couples also suffer with the fear of having the embryos switched during theShow MoreRelatedFrozen Sperm And Frozen Eggs1382 Words   |  6 PagesOver the last few years there have been court battles involving frozen embryos, frozen sperm and frozen eggs. One of the most recent cases is Sofia Vergara and Nick Loeb’s publicized battle over the frozen embryos that they created together in 2013. The decision was made to create the embryos due to Sofia’s age and Nick’s desire to have children. They realized how sophisticated science had become and decided to use the scientific knowledge to their advantage. When they were ready, they would haveRead MoreThe Adoption Process Of The United States1498 Words   |  6 Pagesfamiliar with the traditional adoption process, but few have heard of embryo adoption. Embryo adoption proves to be a great alternative to IUI, IVF, or traditional adoption for couples wanting to have a baby. When a couple decides to try IUI with high powered ovulation drugs or IVF, most of the time they are left with embryos that have not been used. The big question that the couple must decide is what to do with the embryos. The answer to this question carries more weight than many would thinkRead MoreTo Respond Appropriately To The Most Ethically Relevant1246 Words   |  5 Pagesfirst recommendation is to see the case out to the supreme court in support of Peggy. Referring to the Davis v. Davis Case () in 2004, we use the structure used for determining the fate of the embryos in that case and apply it to our case. The court created a hierarchical structure for disposition of the embryos. It follows three steps: first, the preferences of the genetic parents are considered; second, a prior agreement; and third, weighing the interests of the parties. Since the preference of theRead MoreI Find It Ironic That The Star Of The American Sitcom â€Å"Modern1898 Words   |  8 Pagesâ€Å"i nformal† mechanisms, particularly gossip and scandal, which are effective in communicating and enforcing acceptable behavior (Rosen 2008, 16). In the Sofà ­a Vergara article, it is noted that Nick Loeb filed his lawsuit to claim ownership of the former couple’s frozen embryos in a â€Å"desperate attempt to stay in the public eye† (Article). If this statement is true, Nick Loeb obviously understands the importance of fame and kinship within the American culture and is creating this scandal to further improveRead MoreThe Impact of Roe V. Wade1738 Words   |  7 Pagesbegins, which Roe never even touched on, remains a torn in any politician’s side. Due in part to the fact that technology is moving a lot quicker then the law can rule on issues like medical research involving embryos; cloning; behavior of pregnant woman; and the legal ownership of frozen embryos. Anti-abortion activists have been able to chip away at the right and access to an abortion for many women. One of the biggest victories for abortion opponents came in 1992, the case of Planned ParenthoodRead MoreEthical Considerations Behind New Alternatives to Abortion.1566 Words   |  7 Pagesregarding ownership of the embryos and what to consider of unused embryos. In the case of A.Z. v B.Z. in 2000, the disposition upon frozen pre embryos upon separation is the ethical consideration taking place. AZ and BZ underwent IVF treatment and several extra pre embryos were formed. The wife, AZ, used one of the embryos yet no child was produced. After the couple divorced, it was apparent that the consent form signed by the couple had agreed upon separation that the pre embryos would be returnedRead More Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research Essay4185 Words   |  17 Pagesscientists believe that research on human embryonic stem cells, components of human embryos created in laboratorie s, will eventually yield cures to a number of devastating human conditions including juvenile diabetes, Parkinson’s disease and spinal cord injuries. On August 9, 2001, President George W. Bush announced he would permit federally funded research on existing stem cells lines derived from human embryos. He prohibited the federal funding of research on any cell lines created after thatRead MoreMock Strategic Plan For California Hospital Medical Center Essay3834 Words   |  16 Pagespenicillin and in 1984, it began the family medicine residency program in conjunction with the University of Southern California (USC) ongoing today. In 1986 the hospital opened the California Reproductive Health Institute, where the first successful frozen embryo transfer in the nation was achieved. In 2002, the hospital opened the Los Angeles center for women s health to provide specialty care programs for women and today, the hospital runs the only Level 11 trauma center in Los Angeles (CHMC, n d).